The Bison Haze: A Yellowstone Controversy

Comments

1. 

   jjordan

   May 11, 2008

   Thanks Ralph, Just watched all three parts, Not Real impressed, No depth, and a lot of footage that could have been left out.

2. 

   dbaileyhill

   May 12, 2008

   I also watched all three parts. The people who filmed this said it an “art film” , a different kind of art genre. I have seen many art films/videos, live video installations, all over the world, and some really far-out work but in my professional opinion it fell short. They claimed to show all sides of the controversy and i do not agree that they did. I was very disappointed. There was an interesting discussion of the “film” on the New West web-site.
   jjordan’s comment reflects that of the posts at New West.
   I read the discussion then watched each part first without sound and then with sound. In my opinion, the film is not effective in conveying what is happening to the bison.
   I posted after i read the comments, but decided not to post again after watching, as I don’t have anything positive to say about it and my impression of the comments written by a couple of people involved with the film, is that they don’t seem to want to have a “real” discussion about the “film”.

3. 

   Tom Rice

   May 12, 2008

   There’s a fourth film on that site titled “Bison Bison.” It’s about the latest buffalo hunt at Yellowstone, and both hunters and Buffalo Field Campaign volunteers are interviewed.

4. 

   Tom Rice

   May 12, 2008

   Sorry, that film I mention above is footage from last year’s hunt.

5. 

   jjordan

   May 14, 2008

   Time arrives for captured bison to return to park
   http://billingsgazette.net/articles/2008/05/14/news/state/41-bison.txt