Expand the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness

 

The Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness encompasses Montana’s highest peaks and some of the most extensive area above timberline in the lower 48 states. Photo George Wuerthner

By Phil Knight and George Wuerthner, Gallatin Yellowstone Wilderness Alliance  www.gallatinyellowstonewilderness.org

 

It’s time to expand the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness in Montana and Wyoming. 300,000 acres could be added to this iconic and rugged wilderness.

 

Beartooth Front proposed additions to the AB Wilderness stretches from Red Lodge to Nye near the Stillwater River. Photo George Wuerthner 

 

Wilderness areas everywhere are under pressure from climate change, air pollution, extinction, extreme wildfires, invasive species, motor vehicle trespass  and heavy human use. Let’s set aside as much land as we can, while we can.

 

Every day there are more people on Earth than there have ever been before. The impacts of our swelling and needy species are ever more obvious as industrial civilization and its addiction to fossil fuels wreaks havoc on the Earth’s life-support systems.

Head of the East Boulder River. Photo George Wuerthner 

We need to take many drastic steps to curb our consumption and try to blunt the impacts of climate change and other unfolding disasters. One way to do this is to protect more land from development. Scientist E.O. Wilson called for restoring and protecting 50% of Earth’s land as protected reserves. President Biden has initiated a plan to protect 30% of US lands and waters by 2030.

 

The 30×30 Initiative (renamed the America the Beautiful Initiative) (which originated from Sierra Club and other NGOs) seeks to reverse the negative impacts of biodiversity decline and climate change by protecting more natural areas, and to increase access to nature for communities that lack it.

Mule Deer. Photo George Wuerthner

30×30 is an ambitious agenda considering we are at about 12% protected US land currently, with much of that in Alaska. No doubt this proposal will get watered down and reduced with the definition of “protected” being very slippery. Already Republicans are howling against this initiative calling it, predictably, a land grab. Do they offer any alternative to help with climate change or endangered species or anything else to do with the environment?  Of course not.

The Forest Service is logging the forest in the name of “forest health” and fire prevention, but removing carbon that would slow global warming. Kirk Hill by Bozeman. Photo George Wuerthner 

Protecting more land through a variety of designations will help with climate change in several ways:

-Carbon sequestration

-More uninhabited areas to absorb extreme weather and fires

-More room for stressed and migrating animals and plants to move

-Storage and release of fresh water (though sometimes that water gets too abundant, and turns into floods, overall the West is in severe drought).

-Places for humans to relax and unwind in nature

-https://www.fs.usda.gov/ccrc/topics/wilderness

Road along Gardiner River washed out by floods. Yellowstone NP, Montana Photo George Wuerthner

Here in the Northern Rocky Mountains we can add more protected land more readily than most areas of the US. We still have a fair piece of undeveloped land, and most of it is public. But even here ecosystems are unraveling and climate change is hitting hard. Take the Yellowstone floods of June 2022.

 

On June 13, 2022 record-breaking floods came roaring out of every canyon in the Beartooth and Absaroka ranges of Montana. Heavy late season snowfall combined with up to 8 inches of rain produced massive amounts of water, all of it spilling out of the dozens of major creeks and rivers and causing havoc and destruction. The floods were record-breaking, with the Yellowstone River topping 50,000 cubic feet per second (the previous record was 38,000). Roads in and near Yellowstone National Park were destroyed. The towns of Gardiner and Cooke City were cut off completely for a few days and access to the Park is still compromised.

Grizzly bears are expanding their range into many of the northern roadless lands of the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. Designation of these lands as wilderness would ensure the bear’s habitrat is intact. Photo George Wuerthner 

The drainages on the north side of the immense Beartooth Mountains, Montana’s highest range, went berserk. The town of Red Lodge was hit with extreme, cold, fast-moving floods, damaging and destroying many homes, roads and bridges. On East Rosebud Creek three miles of road was obliterated, cutting off all vehicle access to vacation homes and popular trailheads. Similar damage was inflicted on Montana towns and infrastructure along many other major creeks and rivers.

Much of the area proposed as additions to the Absaraoka Beartooth Wilderness is critical elk habitat. Photo George Wuerthner 

 

Climate change is clearly here and is impossible to ignore. Bozeman, where I live, just had its hottest August on record. As I write it is forecast to hit 97 here tomorrow, September 3. The heat across the West right now is crushing, with records being broken everywhere.

 

One way to mitigate and offset climate change, and many other problems, is to get Congress to designate more Wilderness. Other designations like national monument or national park would offer some protection, but designated Wilderness – requiring an act of Congress – is the gold standard for wildlands protection. It keeps out motor vehicles and wheeled vehicles and keeps the land in a primitive state where “man (and woman) is just a visitor.” People are welcome to visit but must travel by foot or animal only.

East Rosebud Lake and peaks of the Beartooth Range. Photo George Wuerthner

Picture high, cool mountains with rushing creeks, cold lakes and glaciers. The Absaroka-Beartooth Wilderness, designated in 1978, covers 940,000 acres in the Custer Gallatin National Forest in Montana and the Shoshone National Forest in Wyoming. This magnificent wilderness, encompassing most of the highest mountains in Montana, vast stretches of alpine tundra and hundreds of lakes, extends along the northern border of Yellowstone National Park and makes up a major portion of the world-famous Greater Yellowstone Ecosystem (GYE). Thanks mainly to large areas of protected land, the GYE has held on to all of its 66 native mammal species, true of few places on Earth.

The Stillwater River near Nye Montana. Photo George Wuerthner 

Nearly 300,000 acres of unprotected roadless lands surround the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. This roadless public land, still pristine despite the endless development of the West, is what you might call the “low-hanging fruit” for 30×30 protection. The footwork has been done, the maps drawn. All it requires is an act of Congress. Montana has 6 million acres of potential Wilderness still, sitting in limbo, nominally protected by the Roadless Rule but still subject to the whims of the Forest Service and its predilection for logging and road building.

 

Some may say it is unreasonable or impractical to set aside more land from development, and to expand existing wilderness areas. But I will remind you that the Absaroka-Beartooth was slated to be cut in half by an existing motor vehicle trail that ran north to south across the middle of the mountains. Stalwart wilderness defenders refused to give in and the motorized route was closed and included in the wilderness.

Camp on Line Creek Plateau proposed addition to AB Wilderness. Photo George Wuerthner 

There are many potential additions to the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. Gallatin Yellowstone Wilderness Alliance has identified 22 areas in all. Starting in the east, there is the Line Creek Plateau near Red Lodge.  Steep timbered canyons flank this high alpine grassland which supports twenty rare or uncommon plants. The plateau is over 10,000 feet in elevation. The Custer Gallatin National Forest has recommended for wilderness only 801 acres out of 32,983 roadless acres, with some of the acreage on the Shoshone National Forest. The plateau is so special that the Forest Service has designated 16,127 acres as the Line Creek Research Natural Area. At least 30,000 acres should be recommended for wilderness.

West Fork Rock Creek. Custer Gallatin NF, Montana Photo George Wuerthner 

The West Fork and Lake Fork of Rock Creek near Red Lodge and the Beartooth Front from Red Lodge to the East Rosebud drainage comprise 34,640 acres of roadless lands adjacent to the existing Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness that includes 27 miles of trail. The West Fork of Rock Creek is the municipal watershed for Red Lodge and originates in some of the most highest and spectacular mountains in Montana.  In particular, all the roadless lands in both the glaciated valleys of the West and Lake Forks of Rock Creek should be recommended as wilderness.

Upper Rock Creek near Red Lodge Montana. Photo George Wuerthner 

The 25,000 acre East Rosebud to Stillwater roadless area along the Beartooth Front provides for the access to East and West Rosebud, as well as Stillwater trailheads. All should be protected as wilderness.

Deer Creek drainage, one of the largest roadless areas adjacent to AB Wilderness. Photo George Wuerthner 

Along the north face of the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness are any number of roadless lands that should be added to the list of recommended wildernesses, including the 129,000 Deer Creek drainage lying between the Boulder River and Stillwater River, and includes lands surrounding the East Boulder, Lower Deer Creek, Upper Deer Creek and Bridger Creek. This type of foothills landscape is largely missing from the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness.  It is important elk and deer habitat, not to mention genetically pure Yellowstone Cutthroat Trout in the upper Deer Creek drainages. At least half of this area could be managed reasonably well as wilderness.

The 5,000 acre Mount Rae roadless area between the Boulder and West Boulder Rivers is another area with aspen and meadows and good wildlife habitat.

The Tie Creek area features low elevation meadows important for big game habitat. Photo George Wuerthner 

The 8,000 acre Tie Creek/Mission Creek/Livingston Peak roadless area including the north face of Shell Mountain with trailhead access near the 63 Ranch. Livingston Peak provides the scenic backdrop to Livingston. Little Mission and Mission Creek both harbor genetically pure Cutthroat Trout. All of this area should be protected.

 

Paradise Face from the Yellowstone River. Photo George Wuerthner

In Paradise Valley, much of the lower foothills of the Absaroka Mountains are not within the wilderness, the entire roadless terrain of 13,000 acres from Deep Creek to Strawberry Creek along the Absaroka Front should be added to the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. This area was threatened several years ago by illegal motorized trail construction by a local rancher.

Emigrant Peak provides a prominant backdrop to Paradise Valley. Photo George Wuerthner 

Providing a scenic backdrop for Paradise Valley, Chico Peak, Emigrant Peak and Dome Mountain’s 56,000 acre roadless area reaches from Cedar Creek near Gardiner north to Passage Creek in the Mill Creek drainage. Except for existing mineral claims, the entire area should also be added to the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. These lands are critical migration corridors and winter range for elk and bison moving north from Yellowstone as well as important grizzly bear habitat. Six Mile Creek has pure Yellowstone Cutthroat trout populations. Not long ago Congress passed a bill to stop the proposed gold mine in Emigrant Gulch, showing how valuable these lands are to the American people.

Looking north towards Six Mile Creek drainage from near the summit of Emigrant Peak. Photo George Wuerthner 

The Gallatin Yellowstone Wilderness Act would designate all of these areas and more as Wilderness, for a total of 1.1 million acres across the Custer Gallatin in the Northern Greater Yellowstone area of Montana. For details on each of the 22 proposed additions to the Absaroka Beartooth see www.gallatinyellowstonewilderness.org and look under “Wildlands.”

Dailey Lake and Dome Mountain, some of the most important winter range north of Yellowstone. Photo George Wuerthner 

The Northern Rockies Ecosystem Protection Act would also expand the Absaroka Beartooth Wilderness. NREPA has been around for 25 years and has been introduced into every session of Congress since. It would designate 22 million acres of new Wilderness across Montana, Wyoming, Idaho, and Eastern Washing ton and Oregon.  Allianceforthewildrockies.org